What is compared, and how
Before. Each existing debt is carried forward on its own, at its own rate and the repayment you make now, until it is cleared. The number of months and the interest come from the fixed-repayment formula, with a smaller final repayment for whatever is left:
n = −ln(1 − B × r ÷ PMT) ÷ ln(1 + r)
The “before” interest is the sum across the debts, and the “before” payoff time is that of the slowest debt. Each repayment is assumed to stop when its own debt is cleared.
After. The new loan pays out all the balances. Its repayment comes from the standard loan formula:
PMT = L × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n)
B is a debt’s balance and L is the new loan amount: the balances added together, plus the upfront fee if it is added to the loan. r is the monthly rate as a decimal (yearly rate ÷ 12 ÷ 100), n the number of monthly repayments, PMT the monthly repayment and ln the natural logarithm.
Total cost of the new loan = interest + upfront fee + monthly fee × n
The comparison that matters is total cost against the interest you would otherwise pay, not repayment against repayment.
Worked example: three debts into one 11% loan
| Debt | Balance | Rate | Repayment | Cleared in | Interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Credit card 1 | $6,000 | 20% | $180 | 50 months | $2,830.91 |
| Credit card 2 | $3,000 | 18% | $90 | 47 months | $1,190.16 |
| Personal loan | $8,000 | 13% | $260 | 38 months | $1,784.10 |
Before: $17,000 owing, $530 a month, 50 months until the last debt is cleared and $5,805.18 of interest. The average rate, weighted by balance, is 16.35%.
The new loan is at 11% over 5 years with a $300 upfront fee added to the loan:
- L = $17,000 + $300 = $17,300. r = 11% ÷ 12 = 0.0091667, and n = 60.
- 1.0091667−60 = 0.578397, and 1 − 0.578397 = 0.421603.
- PMT = $17,300 × 0.0091667 ÷ 0.421603 = $158.58 ÷ 0.421603 = $376.14 a month.
- Interest = 60 × $376.14 − $17,300 = $5,268.64 (using the unrounded repayment). Total cost = $5,268.64 + $300 = $5,568.64.
After: $376.14 a month, which is $153.86 less; 60 months, which is 10 longer; and a total cost of $5,568.64, which is $236.55 less than the $5,805.18 of interest before. A rate more than five points lower produces only a small saving, because the debt is being carried for ten more months.
A lower repayment is not the same as a lower cost
Stretch the same loan to 7 years and the repayment drops to $296.22, which is $233.78 a month less than now. But the interest rises to $7,582.32 and the total cost to $7,882.32, which is $2,077.14 more than leaving the debts as they are. The rate fell; the cost rose, because the balance is outstanding for 84 months rather than 50. The calculator flags this case whenever the new repayment is lower and the total cost is higher.
The reverse also holds. Over 3 years the repayment is $566.38, slightly more than now, and the total cost is $3,389.67, a saving of $2,415.51.
A fair test separates the effect of the rate from the effect of the term: keep paying what you pay now. Putting the current $530 a month into the 11% loan clears it in 39 months and costs $3,651.56 including the fee, $2,153.62 less than before and 11 months sooner. The calculator shows this line under the comparison.
The break-even rate is the new-loan rate at which, over the chosen term and with the fees entered, the total cost equals what you would pay now. For the 5-year loan it is 11.46%; for the 7-year loan it is 8.21%. A quoted rate above the break-even figure costs more overall.
What is and is not included
- Included: an upfront fee (added to the loan or paid separately) and a monthly fee on the new loan.
- Not included: fees for paying out the existing debts early, any change in rate over time, and tax. Add known payout fees to the upfront fee to count them.
- Card repayments are held level. If you only pay a card’s minimum, which falls as the balance falls, the card will take longer and cost more than the “before” figures show.
- No new borrowing. The comparison assumes the paid-out cards are not used again. If they are, the old debts return alongside the new loan.
- A debt whose repayment does not cover its interest never clears, so no “before” total can be given; the calculator says which debt it is.
- No lender’s terms or any country’s rules are applied, and nothing here says whether a particular loan is suitable for you.
Related calculators
- Debt payoff calculator (pay the debts down without a new loan)
- Personal loan calculator
- Credit cards payoff calculator
- Interest rate calculator
- Loan calculator