Three ways to repay a loan, three formulas
Interest is always charged on the amount still owing. What separates one loan type from another is how quickly that amount comes down. The faster the debt shrinks, the less interest there is to pay, even at an identical rate.
Regular repayments (an amortised loan)
Every repayment is the same size. Part of it pays that month’s interest and the rest reduces the debt, so the balance reaches zero with the last repayment.
Repayment = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n)
Interest only, principal at the end
Each month you pay only the interest, so the debt never falls. The full amount borrowed is due with the final payment.
Monthly payment = P × r Total interest = P × r × n
One lump sum at the end
Nothing is paid during the term. Unpaid interest is added to the debt each compounding period and then attracts interest itself.
Amount due = P × (1 + i)m
In all three, P is the amount borrowed, r is the monthly interest rate as a decimal (the yearly rate ÷ 12) and n is the number of months. For the lump sum, i is the rate for one compounding period (the yearly rate ÷ the number of compounding periods in a year) and m is the number of compounding periods in the term.
Worked example: $20,000 at 9% for 5 years
The monthly rate is 9% ÷ 12 = 0.75%, so r = 0.0075, and there are 5 × 12 = 60 months.
- Regular repayments. 1.0075−60 = 0.638700, and 1 − 0.638700 = 0.361300. $20,000 × 0.0075 = $150, and $150 ÷ 0.361300 = $415.17 a month. Sixty repayments total $24,910.03 (using the repayment before it is rounded to the cent), so the interest is $4,910.03.
- Interest only. $20,000 × 0.0075 = $150 a month. Over 60 months that is $9,000 of interest, and the $20,000 is still owed at the end. Total repaid: $29,000.
- Lump sum, compounding monthly. 1.007560 = 1.565681, and $20,000 × 1.565681 = $31,313.62 due at the end. The interest is $11,313.62.
One rate, three very different bills. Interest only costs about 1.8 times as much interest as regular repayments, and the lump sum about 2.3 times as much.
Why the totals differ so much
With regular repayments the average amount owing across the term is a little over half the loan, so you pay interest on roughly half the money for the full five years. With interest only you owe the whole $20,000 for the whole term. With a lump sum you owe more every month, because the interest you have not paid is added to the debt.
That last effect is compounding, and you can measure it. The interest-only loan and the lump-sum loan both leave the $20,000 untouched for five years. The only difference is whether interest is paid as it falls due. Leaving it unpaid costs $11,313.62 − $9,000 = $2,313.62 extra, which is purely interest charged on interest.
How often interest compounds matters as well. If the same lump-sum loan compounds once a year, the amount due is $20,000 × 1.095 = $30,772.48, which is $541.14 less than with monthly compounding. When you are quoted a rate on a lump-sum loan, ask how often interest is added.
Common mistakes when comparing loans
- Comparing only the monthly payment. $150 a month looks far cheaper than $415.17, but the interest-only loan costs $4,089.97 more in total and leaves you needing $20,000 on the last day.
- Forgetting the final payment. For interest-only and lump-sum loans the real question is where the final amount will come from. If the plan is to refinance, the cost of the new loan belongs in the comparison too.
- Ignoring fees. This calculator covers interest only. To include an upfront fee that is added to the loan, add it to the amount borrowed.
The figures assume a fixed rate, monthly payments made on time and no early repayment. A lender’s own schedule may differ by a few cents because of rounding and the exact number of days in each month.