How a personal loan with fees is calculated
A personal loan is repaid in equal instalments, so the repayment comes from the standard loan formula. What changes with fees is which figures go into it and how much money you end up holding.
Repayment = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n) + monthly fee
P is the balance interest is charged on. If the establishment fee is added to the loan, P is the loan amount plus the fee and you receive the full loan amount. If the fee is taken out of the loan, P is the loan amount and you receive that amount less the fee. r is the yearly interest rate ÷ 12, as a decimal. n is the number of monthly repayments.
Cost of borrowing = repayment × n − money received
That cost is interest plus every fee. To express it as one yearly rate, the calculator finds the rate at which a fee-free loan of the money you received would need the same repayments. It is solved by trial because no formula gives it directly; the APR calculator shows that search step by step.
For an early payout, the balance still owing after k repayments is:
Balance after k repayments = P × (1 + r)k − R × ((1 + r)k − 1) ÷ r
R is the repayment before the monthly fee is added, and k is the number of repayments already made.
Worked example: $15,000 at 12% over 3 years
The lender charges a $300 establishment fee, added to the loan, and $10 a month.
- Balance that earns interest. $15,000 + $300 = $15,300. You receive $15,000.
- Rate and number of repayments. r = 0.12 ÷ 12 = 0.01 and n = 3 × 12 = 36.
- The bracket. (1.01)−36 = 0.698925, and 1 − 0.698925 = 0.301075.
- Repayment. $15,300 × 0.01 = $153, and $153 ÷ 0.301075 = $508.18. Add the $10 fee: $518.18 a month.
- Total repaid. $518.18 × 36 = $18,654.44 (using the unrounded repayment).
- Cost of borrowing. $18,654.44 − $15,000 = $3,654.44, made up of $2,994.44 of interest and $660 of fees ($300 + 36 × $10).
- Yearly rate with fees. A fee-free $15,000 loan needs repayments of $518.18 when its rate is 14.75% a year, so that is the fee-inclusive rate. Counting monthly compounding, it is an effective 15.79% a year.
With no fees at all the same loan would cost $498.21 a month and $2,935.73 in interest. The fees therefore cost their $660 face value plus $58.71 of extra interest, because the financed $300 is borrowed money too.
Added to the loan or taken out of it
If the $300 is taken out of the loan instead, you sign for $15,000 but only $14,700 arrives. The repayment drops to $508.21 and the total repaid to $18,295.73, which looks cheaper, yet the fee-inclusive rate is 14.81%: slightly higher, because the same fee is measured against less money. When a specific sum is needed in hand, the loan amount has to be raised by the fee, which brings you back to the first case.
What paying out early really saves
After 18 of the 36 repayments, the example loan still has $8,333.25 owing. By hand: (1.01)18 = 1.196147; $15,300 × 1.196147 = $18,301.05; $508.18 × 0.196147 ÷ 0.01 = $9,967.80; and $18,301.05 − $9,967.80 = $8,333.25. Half the term has passed but about 54% of the debt remains, because early repayments are mostly interest.
Paying that balance out brings the total paid to $17,660.48, a saving of $993.97 on the full term. The saving is real, but the establishment fee has now bought only 18 months of credit, so the fee-inclusive rate for the money you actually used rises a little, to 14.81%. An early repayment fee changes the picture more: with a $150 charge the saving falls to $843.97 and the rate becomes 15.55%. Paying out after only 6 months, with no exit fee, gives 17.21%.
Reading a personal loan offer
- The rate is not the cost. Two loans at the same interest rate can differ by hundreds of dollars once fees are counted. Compare the total repaid and the fee-inclusive rate.
- A monthly fee is paid to the end. It is the same $10 in the last month, when little is owed, as in the first. On small loans it can outweigh the interest.
- Check which figure is the loan amount. A quote for “$15,000” may mean $15,000 received or $15,000 owed before the fee is taken out. The gap is the establishment fee.
- Longer terms lower the repayment and raise the total. Change the term to see both move.
The figures assume a fixed rate and interest charged monthly on the reducing balance. Variable rates, repayment holidays, fortnightly schedules and penalty fees are outside this calculation, and rates a lender is required to disclose follow rules that differ from country to country.