How the plan is built
There is no single formula for several cards on one budget, because the amount each card receives changes as others are cleared. The calculator runs the same four steps every month until nothing is owing:
1. Interest: each balance × its yearly rate ÷ 12 is added to that card.
2. Minimums: every card receives its minimum repayment (or its whole balance, if smaller).
3. Spare money = budget − the minimums just paid. It goes to the first card in the order; anything left over once that card is clear goes to the next.
4. When a card is cleared, its minimum stays in the budget and joins the spare money.
Step 4 is what makes the plan speed up over time: the total paid each month stays the same, so every card that disappears makes the payment on the next one larger. The two orders differ only in step 3. Highest rate first (often called the avalanche method) targets the card charging the most interest. Smallest balance first (often called the snowball method) targets the card that can be finished soonest. The order is fixed from the starting figures.
Worked example: three cards and $400 a month
| Card | Balance | Rate | Minimum |
|---|---|---|---|
| Card 1 | $6,000 | 22% | $120 |
| Card 2 | $2,500 | 18% | $50 |
| Card 3 | $1,000 | 13% | $25 |
- The minimums total $120 + $50 + $25 = $195, so $400 − $195 = $205 is spare each month.
- Month 1 interest: $6,000 × 22% ÷ 12 = $110.00; $2,500 × 18% ÷ 12 = $37.50; $1,000 × 13% ÷ 12 = $10.83. Together, $158.33.
- Highest rate first sends the spare $205 to Card 1, which receives $120 + $205 = $325. Its balance becomes $6,000 + $110 − $325 = $5,785.00. Card 2 becomes $2,500 + $37.50 − $50 = $2,487.50 and Card 3 becomes $1,000 + $10.83 − $25 = $985.83.
- Smallest balance first sends the $205 to Card 3 instead, which receives $230 and falls to $780.83, while Card 1 receives only its $120 minimum and falls to $5,990.00.
Carried through to the end:
| Approach | Cards cleared in month | Finished | Interest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Highest rate first | Card 1: 23, Card 2: 29, Card 3: 31 | 31 months | $2,560.77 |
| Smallest balance first | Card 3: 5, Card 2: 14, Card 1: 32 | 32 months | $2,922.24 |
| Minimums only, each card alone | Card 3: 53, Card 2: 94, Card 1: 137 | 137 months | $12,887.11 |
Reading the comparison
Highest rate first always costs the least interest, because every spare dollar goes where it stops the most interest. Here it saves $361.47 and one month over smallest balance first. What smallest balance first offers is earlier milestones: the first card is gone in month 5 rather than month 23, and two cards are gone by month 14. The calculator shows both sets of figures and leaves the choice to you.
The gap between the two orders depends on your cards. If the smallest balance also has the highest rate, the two orders are identical. If the rates are close together, the difference is small. It is largest when a big balance carries a much higher rate than the small ones.
The third row is the most striking. On the fixed dollar minimums alone, with each repayment stopping when its card is cleared, the same debt takes 137 months (11 years 5 months) and $12,887.11 in interest. The extra $205 a month, together with rolling each cleared card’s minimum onto the next, removes about four-fifths of that interest.
About the minimums
Enter each minimum as the dollar amount on your latest statement. Real minimums are usually a percentage of the balance and fall as the balance falls; this plan holds each one at the figure you enter, so it never pays a card less than you are paying now. If your budget is less than the minimums added together, the plan cannot run and the calculator tells you the shortfall. If a minimum is smaller than that card’s monthly interest, its balance grows until the spare money reaches it.
For the effect of a percentage minimum on a single card, see the credit card calculator. For a mix of cards and loans with payoff dates, see the debt payoff calculator.
Assumptions and limits
- No new purchases, fees, interest-free periods or promotional rates. No card issuer’s terms are applied.
- Interest is one-twelfth of the yearly rate on the balance each month; cards generally charge it daily, so statements will differ a little.
- Amounts are not rounded to the cent month by month, and the final month’s payment is whatever remains.
- The plan stops at 100 years and reports that the cards are not cleared.
Related calculators
- Credit card calculator (one card, percentage minimums)
- Debt payoff calculator
- Debt consolidation calculator
- Budget calculator