What a fee-inclusive rate measures
The interest rate on a loan contract, the nominal rate, only prices the interest. Fees are a cost of borrowing too, and they do not all behave the same way: an upfront fee reduces the money you walk away with, while an ongoing fee raises every repayment. An annual percentage rate (APR) folds both into a single yearly figure by asking one question: at what interest rate would a fee-free loan of the money you actually received need exactly the repayments you actually make?
Start with the ordinary repayment on the contract.
Repayment = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n)
P is the amount the interest is charged on (the loan amount, plus the upfront fees if they are added to the loan). r is the nominal rate per repayment period as a decimal, the yearly rate ÷ 12 for monthly repayments. n is the number of repayments.
Then write down what really changes hands and solve for the rate that makes the two sides equal.
A = (repayment + f) × (1 − (1 + i)−n) ÷ i
A is the net amount received: the loan amount less any fees paid at the start. f is the ongoing fee per repayment. i is the unknown fee-inclusive rate per period. No algebra isolates i, so it is found by trial: guess a rate, work out the right-hand side, and move the guess up if the answer is above A or down if it is below. The calculator halves the range each time until it settles.
Fee-inclusive rate = i × periods per year
Effective annual rate = (1 + i)periods per year − 1
The first is quoted the same way as a nominal rate, so the two can be put side by side. The second also counts the effect of interest being charged every period instead of once a year, which is why it is always the larger figure.
Worked example: $20,000 at 9% with $400 upfront and $10 a month
The loan runs for 5 years with monthly repayments. The $400 is paid at the start, so it comes out of the money received.
- Repayment on the contract. r = 0.09 ÷ 12 = 0.0075 and n = 60. (1.0075)−60 = 0.638700, so 1 − 0.638700 = 0.361300. $20,000 × 0.0075 = $150, and $150 ÷ 0.361300 = $415.17 a month.
- What you really pay and receive. Each month costs $415.17 + $10 = $425.17. You receive $20,000 − $400 = $19,600.
- First trial, 10% a year. At i = 0.10 ÷ 12, sixty payments of $425.17 are worth $20,010.78 today. That is more than $19,600, so the rate must be higher.
- Second trial, 11%. The payments are worth $19,554.86, which is too little, so the rate lies between 10% and 11%.
- Narrow it down. 10.5% gives $19,780.96 (still too much); 10.9% gives $19,599.78, within a few cents of $19,600.
- Result. The fee-inclusive rate is 10.90% a year against a nominal 9%. As an effective annual rate it is 11.46%; the nominal rate alone, compounded monthly, is an effective 9.38%.
Over the five years you repay $25,510.03 for the use of $19,600: $4,910.03 of interest and $1,000 of fees.
How to read the result
Small fees move the rate more than they seem to
In the example, $1,000 of fees on a $20,000 loan adds 1.90 percentage points to the rate. The $400 upfront fee alone would lift 9% to 9.87%, and the $10 monthly fee alone to 10.02%. A flat monthly fee is the same dollar amount late in the loan when little is still owed, so it weighs more heavily than its size suggests.
The shorter the loan, the bigger the effect
The same $400 and $10 a month on a one-year loan produce a fee-inclusive rate of 13.91%, because the upfront fee is spread over twelve months instead of sixty. The same thing happens when a loan is paid out early: the fee-inclusive rate you end up paying is higher than the one calculated for the full term.
Adding the fee to the loan
If the $400 is financed instead, you receive the full $20,000 and repay $433.47 a month. The fee-inclusive rate is 10.86%, almost the same, but the fee now attracts interest as well: total interest rises from $4,910.03 to $5,008.23.
Compare like with like
Put nominal beside nominal and effective beside effective. An effective annual rate on one loan is not comparable with a nominal rate on another. Fee-inclusive rates are also only comparable between loans of a similar size and term, since a fixed fee is a larger share of a small or short loan.
Limits of the method
The calculation assumes a fixed rate, equal repayments and every repayment made on time for the full term. It includes only the fees you enter; late fees, early repayment charges and insurance are left out unless you add them. Each country sets its own rules for the rate a lender must disclose, including which fees are counted and whether a standard loan size and term are assumed, so this figure is a way to compare offers on equal terms, not a restatement of any official disclosure.