How each of the three results is worked out
Minimum repayments: month by month
A minimum repayment is usually a small percentage of the balance with a dollar floor. Because it is recalculated every month from a falling balance, there is no tidy formula for the payoff time, so the calculator steps through the months:
balance after interest = B × (1 + r)
minimum = the larger of m × that balance and the floor F (or the whole balance, if smaller)
new B = balance after interest − minimum
While the percentage sets the minimum, each month multiplies the balance by the same factor, which does give a formula for the balance after k months:
Bk = B0 × ((1 + r) × (1 − m))k
A fixed repayment, and a deadline
n = −ln(1 − B × r ÷ PMT) ÷ ln(1 + r)
PMT = B × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n)
B is the balance owing, r the monthly interest rate as a decimal (the yearly rate ÷ 12 ÷ 100), m the minimum percentage as a decimal, F the floor, PMT a fixed monthly repayment, n the number of months and ln the natural logarithm. The first of the two fixed-repayment formulas gives the months for a chosen repayment; the second gives the repayment for a chosen number of months.
Worked example: $5,000 at 20% with a 2% minimum and a $25 floor
- Monthly rate: 20% ÷ 12 = 1.6667%, so r = 0.016667. The first month’s interest is $5,000 × 0.016667 = $83.33, making the balance $5,083.33.
- First minimum: 2% × $5,083.33 = $101.67, which is more than the $25 floor. Of that, $83.33 is interest and only $18.33 reduces the debt. The new balance is $4,981.67.
- The monthly factor is 1.016667 × 0.98 = 0.996333, so the balance falls by just 0.37% a month. After a year it is $5,000 × 0.99633312 = $4,784.38; after five years, $4,010.97; after ten, $3,217.58.
- In month 383 the balance has fallen far enough that 2% of it is less than $25, and the floor takes over. From there the card is cleared in month 486.
Minimum repayments alone take 486 months (40 years 6 months) and cost $18,499.94 in interest, more than three and a half times the original debt.
A fixed $150 a month: B × r ÷ PMT = $83.33 ÷ $150 = 0.555556, ln(1 − 0.555556) = −0.810930, ln(1.016667) = 0.016529, and n = 0.810930 ÷ 0.016529 = 49.1. That is 49 repayments of $150 and a small final one: 50 months (4 years 2 months) and $2,359.09 in interest.
Clear in 24 months: 1.016667−24 = 0.672534, so PMT = $83.33 ÷ (1 − 0.672534) = $254.48 a month, with $1,107.50 in interest. Over 36 months it is $185.82 a month and $1,689.45.
Why minimum repayments take so long
Two things work together. First, the minimum is set only slightly above the interest. In the example the card charges 1.67% a month and the minimum is 2%, so about five-sixths of every minimum repayment is interest. Second, the minimum shrinks as the balance shrinks. Each small win lowers the next repayment, so the payoff never gathers pace.
The second effect is easy to remove. Keep paying the first month’s minimum, $101.67, every month instead of letting it fall, and the card is clear in 104 months (8 years 8 months) for $5,536.20 in interest. The outlay in month one is the same; the difference of almost 32 years comes entirely from not following the minimum down.
The rule itself matters just as much. With a 3% minimum the same card takes 178 months (14 years 10 months) and $5,412.71 in interest. With 1.5% it would never be repaid, because 1.5% of the balance is less than the 1.67% interest added each month; only the floor, once it applies, could rescue it, and here it does not.
Assumptions and limits
- No new spending. The card is not used again. Any new purchases extend every figure on this page.
- Monthly interest. Interest is taken as one-twelfth of the yearly rate on the balance each month. Cards generally charge interest daily and may apply different rates to purchases, cash advances and balance transfers, so a statement will differ somewhat.
- The minimum rule is yours to set. Card issuers use different percentages and floors, and some add fees or interest on top of the percentage. The 2% and $25 shown at first are placeholders, not any issuer’s terms. Use the figures on your statement.
- No fees, interest-free periods or promotional rates are included.
- The simulation stops at 100 years and reports that the card is not cleared in that time.