How the two offers are compared
Both offers are loans over the same term, so the fair comparison is the total paid under each. With the cash back you borrow less at a higher rate. With the low rate you borrow the full amount more cheaply.
f(r) = r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n)
f(r) is the monthly repayment for each dollar borrowed. r is the monthly rate as a decimal (the yearly rate ÷ 12) and n is the number of monthly repayments. At 0%, f is simply 1 ÷ n.
Cash back: repayment = (L − C) × f(rs)
Low interest: repayment = L × f(rl)
L is the price less your deposit and trade-in. C is the cash back. rs is the monthly rate you pay if you take the cash back and rl is the reduced monthly rate. Because the term is the same, whichever offer has the lower repayment also has the lower total cost, and the gap is the difference in repayments multiplied by n.
Setting the two repayments equal and solving for C gives the cash back at which the choice makes no difference.
Break-even cash back = L × (1 − f(rl) ÷ f(rs))
A cash back above that figure beats the low rate; one below it does not. The calculator also turns the question around and finds the reduced rate that would exactly match the cash back on offer, by trial, since that has no direct formula.
Worked example: $3,000 back at 8.5%, or 2.9%
The car is $40,000, you put in $5,000 and finance the rest over 5 years.
- Amount to finance. L = $40,000 − $5,000 = $35,000, and n = 60.
- Cash back loan. You borrow $35,000 − $3,000 = $32,000 at 8.5%. (1 + 0.085 ÷ 12)−60 = 0.654750, so 1 − 0.654750 = 0.345250. $32,000 × 0.085 ÷ 12 = $226.67, and $226.67 ÷ 0.345250 = $656.53 a month. Interest over the term is $7,391.74.
- Low interest loan. You borrow $35,000 at 2.9%. (1 + 0.029 ÷ 12)−60 = 0.865174, so 1 − 0.865174 = 0.134826. $35,000 × 0.029 ÷ 12 = $84.58, and $84.58 ÷ 0.134826 = $627.35 a month. Interest is $2,641.00.
- Total cost. Deposit plus repayments: $44,391.74 with the cash back and $42,641.00 with the low rate.
- Difference. The low rate costs $29.18 a month less, $1,750.74 over the five years.
- Break-even cash back. Per dollar borrowed, the repayments are $656.53 ÷ $32,000 = 0.0205165 and $627.35 ÷ $35,000 = 0.0179243. $35,000 × (1 − 0.0179243 ÷ 0.0205165) is about $4,422. The dealer would need to offer that much, not $3,000, to match the 2.9% finance.
Seen the other way, $3,000 of cash back at 8.5% is worth the same as a reduced rate of 4.75%. Any reduced rate below that beats it over this term.
Why the term decides it
A cash back is a fixed sum on day one. A rate cut saves a little every month, so it is worth more the longer the loan runs. The same two offers swap places as the term changes:
| Term | Cheaper offer | By | Break-even cash back |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 years | Cash back | $221.02 | $2,805.52 |
| 5 years | Low interest | $1,750.74 | $4,422.22 |
| 7 years | Low interest | $3,853.73 | $5,896.97 |
Over 2 years the break-even is $1,939.34, and $3,000 of cash back cannot be matched even by interest-free finance. At the 5-year term, raising the cash back to $5,000 puts it ahead by $711.25.
What the comparison leaves out
- Paying the loan out early. The comparison assumes the full term. If you clear the loan sooner, the low rate has less time to work while the cash back has already been received in full, so the result shifts towards the cash back.
- Conditions on the low rate. Promotional finance can be limited to shorter terms, particular models or a higher deposit, and may carry its own fees. Enter the term actually available.
- The price itself. If the price you can negotiate differs between the two offers, change the vehicle price or the cash back to match. A discount you would lose under the low rate works like extra cash back.
- Your own rate. The cash back does not have to be paired with the dealer’s standard rate. If another lender will finance the car for less, use that rate in offer A.
- Cash taken as cash. The calculator applies the cash back to the loan. If it is paid to you instead and you borrow the full amount, the loan costs more interest than shown.
Fees, taxes and registration charges are not included, and they differ from place to place. Add any that apply equally to both offers to the price; they do not change which is cheaper.