How renting and buying are compared
Comparing a rent payment with a loan repayment says little, because part of every repayment is kept as equity and the renter keeps the deposit. A fair comparison gives two households the same starting cash and the same monthly spending, and asks which is wealthier after a number of years.
The buyer spends the starting cash on the deposit and buying costs. The renter invests it. Each month both spend the same amount: whoever has the lower housing cost that month invests the difference. At the end the home is sold.
Buyer’s net position = V × (1 − s) − B + buyer’s investments
Renter’s net position = renter’s investments
V = Price × (1 + g)t
B = L × (1 + r)k − M × ((1 + r)k − 1) ÷ r
V is the property value after t years of growth at g a year. s is selling costs as a fraction of the sale price. B is the loan balance after k monthly repayments, where L is the amount borrowed, r is the monthly loan rate (yearly rate ÷ 12) and M is the monthly repayment, L × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n) for a term of n months. Investments start at the deposit plus buying costs for the renter and at zero for the buyer, receive the monthly differences, and compound monthly at a rate equivalent to the yearly investment return. Monthly rent is the weekly rent × 52 ÷ 12 and rises once a year. Running costs are a percentage of the property’s value at the start of each year. The break-even year is the first year-end at which the buyer’s position is at least the renter’s.
Worked example: $700,000 home or $650 a week
Assumptions: 20% deposit, 6% loan over 30 years, buying costs 4%, running costs 1.5% of value a year, property growth 3%, selling costs 2.5%, rent rising 3% a year, investments returning 5%, compared over 10 years.
- Starting cash. Deposit $700,000 × 20% = $140,000, plus buying costs $700,000 × 4% = $28,000: $168,000. The loan is $560,000.
- Repayment. $560,000 at 0.5% a month over 360 months is $3,357.48 a month.
- First month. The buyer pays $3,357.48 plus running costs of $700,000 × 1.5% ÷ 12 = $875, a total of $4,232.48. The renter pays $650 × 52 ÷ 12 = $2,816.67 and invests the difference of $1,415.82.
- Value after 10 years. 1.0310 = 1.343916, so V = $700,000 × 1.343916 = $940,741.47.
- Loan balance after 120 repayments. 1.005120 = 1.819397. $560,000 × 1.819397 − $3,357.48 × 0.819397 ÷ 0.005 = $468,640.06.
- Buyer’s position. Selling costs are 2.5% of $940,741.47 = $23,518.54. $940,741.47 − $23,518.54 − $468,640.06 = $448,582.87.
- Renter’s position. The $168,000 grows to $168,000 × 1.0510 = $273,654.30, and ten years of invested monthly differences add $178,730.72 with their returns: $452,385.02.
- Result. $448,582.87 − $452,385.02 = −$3,802.15. After 10 years renting is ahead by about $3,800, and buying moves ahead in year 11.
Over those ten years the renter pays $387,479 in rent, and the buyer pays $523,269 in repayments and running costs, of which $311,538 is interest. After one year the buyer is $43,924 behind, because the buying and selling costs have been paid and little equity has built up. By year 15 the buyer is $47,741 ahead.
Sensitivity: small changes decide the answer
The example is close to even at ten years, so it shows clearly how much the conclusion depends on assumptions nobody can know in advance. Changing one input at a time:
- Property growth of 2% instead of 3% puts renting ahead by $82,773 at ten years and delays the break-even to year 24. At 4%, buying is ahead by $82,625 and breaks even in year 5.
- Investment return of 4% instead of 5% moves the break-even to year 8. At 7%, buying does not catch up within 50 years.
- Rent of $550 a week instead of $650 delays the break-even to year 35; $750 a week brings it forward to year 6.
- Loan rate of 7% delays the break-even to year 24; 5% brings it forward to year 6.
A one-point change in a single assumption moves the ten-year result by roughly $80,000 either way. The output is best read as a map of which assumptions matter, not as a forecast. The note under the result repeats this test with your own figures.
Reading the result
Time is the main variable. Buying starts behind by the buying and selling costs and catches up only as equity builds. A short stay rarely recovers them.
The renter’s result depends on actually investing. The comparison assumes the renter invests the deposit and every monthly difference, and never spends them. A renter who spends the difference ends up with far less than shown.
Common mistakes. Leaving out running costs such as rates, insurance and maintenance; comparing with rent for a smaller or differently located home; using a property growth rate from a boom period; and treating the repayment as the whole cost of owning.
What is left out. No tax of any kind is modelled, although tax on investment returns, on property gains, and any concessions for buyers can shift the result substantially and differ by country. Rates are held constant, there are no vacancies, moves or renovations, and the non-financial sides of the choice, such as security of tenure and flexibility, are outside the calculation.