How the comparison is made
Refinancing replaces one loan with another of the same size. The comparison needs three things: the repayment on each loan, the interest each will charge, and the one-off cost of moving. Both repayments come from the standard loan formula.
M = B × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)−n)
B is the balance owing (plus the switching costs, if they are added to the new loan). r is the monthly interest rate as a decimal: the yearly rate divided by 12. n is the number of monthly repayments left: years × 12. Total interest on either path is M × n − B. At a 0% rate, M is B ÷ n.
Position after k months = Ikeep(k) − Iswitch(k) − C
Ikeep(k) and Iswitch(k) are the interest charged in the first k months on the current and new loans, taken from each loan’s month-by-month schedule. C is the cost of switching. The break-even month is the first month in which the position is zero or better. Interest is the right thing to count, because every dollar repaid that is not interest reduces what you owe and is still yours.
Worked example: $400,000 from 6.5% to 5.9%
The loan has 25 years left. The new loan also runs 25 years, and switching costs $2,000 paid in cash.
- Current repayment. r = 0.065 ÷ 12 = 0.0054167 and n = 300, giving $2,700.83 a month.
- New repayment. r = 0.059 ÷ 12 = 0.0049167 and n = 300, giving $2,552.81 a month, which is $148.02 less.
- Total interest. Current loan: $2,700.83 × 300 − $400,000 = $410,248.59. New loan: $2,552.81 × 300 − $400,000 = $365,842.96 (both using the unrounded repayment).
- Over the full term. $410,248.59 − $365,842.96 − $2,000 = $42,405.63 in favour of switching.
- First month. Interest is $400,000 × 0.0054167 = $2,166.67 on the current loan and $400,000 × 0.0049167 = $1,966.67 on the new one, a saving of $200.
- Break-even. At about $200 a month, the interest saved passes the $2,000 cost during month 11. After 10 months the position is still 70 cents short.
Why the usual shortcut is only approximate
The quick method divides the cost by the monthly saving in repayments: $2,000 ÷ $148.02 = 13.5, so 14 months. It is later than the 11 months above because the repayment falls by less than the interest does. Of the $200 saved in interest in month one, $148.02 stays in your pocket and the other $51.98 goes to paying the loan down faster. The shortcut ignores that second part.
The shortcut fails badly when the terms differ. Stretch the same refinance to a 30-year term and the repayment drops to $2,372.55, a saving of $328.28 a month, and the shortcut reports a break-even of 7 months. But most of that saving is repayment of principal being postponed, not interest avoided. Counting interest, the break-even is still month 11.
When a lower repayment costs more
On the 30-year version, total interest is $454,116.57. Add the $2,000 cost and switching ends up $45,867.98 more expensive than keeping the current loan, even though the rate is lower and the repayment is $328.28 a month smaller. The running position shows how: switching is ahead from month 11, the lead peaks and then shrinks as the slower-falling balance keeps attracting interest, and from month 241 it is behind. When the current loan would have been finished after 25 years, the refinanced loan still owes $123,016.93. The calculator flags this pattern whenever the repayment falls but interest plus costs rises. Keeping the new term equal to the time left, or continuing to pay the old repayment, removes the effect.
Reading the result
The break-even matters most if you may sell or switch again. If the loan is likely to be repaid or refinanced before the break-even month, the costs are not recovered.
Adding costs to the loan does not make them free. With the $2,000 added to the balance, the new loan is $402,000, the repayment is $2,565.57 and the full-term advantage falls from $42,405.63 to $40,576.42, because the costs now attract interest for 25 years.
Count every cost, and only real ones. Typical items are a discharge fee on the old loan, application or settlement fees on the new one, valuation and registration charges, and any break cost on a fixed rate. These vary by lender and location and are not estimated here. An introductory rate that later reverts to a higher one will also change the answer; the calculation assumes each rate lasts the full term.